1960 –The 1960 baseball record of 14-2 was at the time the best in school history. Peelle’s diamondmen were now advanced as the class of Western New York baseball. COACH: James Peelle FINAL RECORD: 14-2
1961 COACH: Jim Peelle FINAL RECORD: 14-5
1962 COACH: Jim Peelle FINAL RECORD: 14-6
1963 – NCAA Bid – Baseball in 1963 earned its due respect with a 15-3 record and an invite to the NCAA Atlantic Division Tournament. It was the first time baseball had distinguished itself with a tourney bid. COACH: James Peelle FINAL RECORD: 15-3
1964 – Played at Yankee Stadium – A 13-5 record and another invite to the NCAA Atlantic Tournament with two post-season games at Yankee Stadium. COACH: Jim Peelle FINAL RECORD: 13-5
1965 COACH: Jim Peelle FINAL RECORD: 9-3
1966 COACH: Jim Peelle FINAL RECORD: 12-6
1967 – Local Champions – Baseball in 1967, 16-1, was marked by a new brand of college stars on campus. Catcher Brian Hansen led the NCAA College Division batters with a crisp .533 average. For the ninth consecutive season the Bulls won the Western New York Intercollegiate Baseball League, initiated originally by Coach Peelle. COACH: James Peelle FINAL RECORD: 16-1
1968 – Expanded Schedule – The Bulls took a six-game southern trip and played their most extensive schedule to date as Bill Monkarsh takes over the coaching duties. COACH: Bill Monkarsh FINAL RECORD: 19-6-1